For the most part I feel like I'm the conductor on this hippy dippy train and Tony's my co-conductor. He's on board, he's shoveling coal (right, that's what trains run on?) and he's keeping the tiny terrorist in line. But one place where Tony shoves me to the side and drives the train is Princess talk. If you've ever call my daughter a princess immediatly look at Tony. He'll probably scowl and might even admonish you for calling her Princess.
I don't care for the Princess talk either- a princess is really nothing to be admired. Disney Princesses are typically clueless, focused on their beauty, don't have goals, etc. Real royalty, while sometimes better- Princess Diana's humantarian work is to be admired- came to power by taking exploiting and oppressing the masses. I also can't help but wonder if calling a baby "princess" sets the child up for a lifetime of expectations- to be pretty, to be sweet, to expect someone to come in and save you and not encouraging daughters to climb to the top of that corporate ladder, to start her own business, to take risks and to ask for a raise.
There are, like anything, many schools of thought on Princess culture. Some parents consider it a phase and even a rite of passage. My thoughts on it are this: I won't encourage it and will try to keep it out of our house. If princess culture does invade I will try to focus on good, real, historical role models like Princess Diana and not on fictional ones. But if Allison does have a real and true interest I'm not going to ban princess culture from our home, all I can do is try to influence her the best that I can without squashing her spirit.
I recently read an interview with the author who wrote, Cinderella Ate My Daughter. Some excerpts, "
[The] insistence on defining girls and women by how we look and how we relate sexually is not only a way to keep [us] in our place, but a way we keep ourselves there. Obsessing over our appearance is the way we assure ourselves and others around us that even if we’re really successful, we’re not really threatening. [T]he pressures on women to look good from womb to tomb have become more intense and confusing [in part] because we have made so much progress. And the consequences for girls of being prematurely sexualized can be precisely the things we’re trying to avoid, such as negative body image, eating disorders, or depression. One of the things [I found] that surprised me was the relationship between sexualization and disconnection from authentic sexuality: Girls who are sexualized early are more likely to see sexuality as a performance, not as something that they feel internally.
It’s a constructionist view of identity, taken to an extreme degree.
I’ve been thinking a lot more about the way girl power has been contorted into pro-narcissism. My daughter, Daisy, got a make-your-own messenger bag kit for her seventh birthday -- [it’s] a messenger bag that you decorate with iron-on transfers. [Most of] the transfers were pink and orange and purple, hearts and flowers and stars and all the stuff that you would typically expect. But that was not what we noticed. One of the transfers said “spoiled,” another one said “pampered princess,” and a third one said “brat.” And [Daisy] looked at them and said, “Mom, why do they want you to put that on your purse? Isn’t that kind of braggy?” -- which is the worst thing you can say if you’re seven. And I said, “Yeah, I think you’re right. It is kind of braggy.” Somehow the idea of creating a strong sense of self in girls has been distorted by the culture into announcing you’re a spoiled, narcissistic brat -- like that is what signifies confidence. But it’s that sexualized, manipulative femininity.
If you asked what we want for our daughters, we’d want very wonderful, positive, thoughtful things: strong internal sense of self, self-direction and compassion and potential and all of that. And then [we] undercut that with what they’re playing with. The two don’t add up.
From what you say, it seems that well-meaning parents unwittingly cause split-identity problems in girls.
And that well-meaning part is really key. I mean, when you walk into Pottery Barn Kids, it’s like apartheid in there. For girls, it’s hearts and flowers and hula girls -- and the boys have sailboats, trucks, sports. I know somebody who was writing the [Pottery Barn] catalog, who said, “We’ve tried to make more gender-neutral items. And they just don’t sell.” We ended up with sea-creature sheets. So that was sort of neutral. [B]ut eventually your daughter may go, “Uh-uh. I don’t want this.” And if you keep disallowing it, giving her things from the boys’ side of the store, she’ll think you believe the stuff for girls is bad -- and maybe even that being a girl is bad. And that’s a problem, tooYou can’t win, it seems.
Well, I’m not ready to say that. I do think there needs to be more discussion of context, and more assumption that we -- as parents or girl advocates or whatever -- have control over some of this, that we have a say in it. There’s a real incentive, of course, on the part of the people who are creating the culture to make us feel like we don’t have control. That you really don’t have a choice. But you do.
I really do believe that change can be made on a micro level. You can think about it and make decisions about what you buy, what you expose your child to, how you talk about it -- all that stuff. I think it makes a big difference. I mean, I know it does. My daughter was Athena on Halloween this year. That’s a long way from Little Mermaid. One of the ways we countered the princess thing was to read a lot of Greek myths. She needs models of femininity and she needs to act out fantasies that affirm her as a girl. She hooked into Athena -- that’s a lot better than the alternatives."
So, the guidelines we're setting up for ourselves are pretty realistic:
-No "Princess", "Brat", "Spoiled" on clothing, toys, etc.
-No licensed princess character stuff
-Let Allison know we think she's pretty but more importantly, that she's kind-hearted, strong, and awesome
-Encourage her to take risks
-Find female role models that are not focused on how thin/cute they are